The European political and financial elite knows that the war in Ukraine is lost but wants to use it as an opportunity to reach strategy independence from the United States. As the future chancellor of Germany Friedrich Merz said right after his electoral win on Feb 23rd: “It will be an absolute priority for me to strengthen Europe as soon as possible so much that it gradually really achieves independence from the United States.”
Such
strategic independence needs money and investment – a lot of it, not only to
boost defense but much else, like energy and innovation; areas in which Europe
is lagging behind the US and China. In order to have the pretext to implement
this spending plan, the idea among the EU elite is to make sure that the war in
Ukraine does not end quickly enough. That way the conflict can be used to justify
artificially injecting much needed money into the moribund EU economies.
First,
there was a question of providing €20 billion euros of additional military support for Ukraine and that
the EU self-imposed fiscal rules to be loosened using the existing “escape clause” in the event of “exceptional”
circumstances, such as the bogus “defense of Ukraine” excuse. As Bloomberg stated, “under this plan, EU nations would be exempt from debt and deficit
limits when financing military expenditures. This marks a fundamental shift in
EU financial policy, as such exemptions have previously been impossible under
EU rules.”
Indeed, the
EU elite does not want to follow the arbitrary EU fiscal rules: for Paris the
3% limit of budget deficit to GDP is politically painful, and for Berlin the
limit of max 60% of GDP in terms of federal public borrowing seems like an
artificial constraint.
Then there
was a talk of a €700 billion euro defense package. Newsweek stated that : “Baerbock said the package could be worth some 700 billion
euros ($732 billion)”. French President Emmanuel Macron also confirmed this on 2nd March 2025
this. “We will give a mandate to the
European Commission to define our capacity needs for a common defense,” Macron said in
an interview published in several French newspapers. “This massive funding
will probably reach hundreds of billions of euros.”
The
official slogan of “help Ukraine defend itself” will give the EU political and
financial elite an excuse to turn on the spigots of the European Central Bank
at full thrust again; to shower the entire European economy with “free” money,
and shore up its fragile economies, like it did after the euro crisis of 2011,
with the enormous COVID
recovery fund
in 2021, as well as with the Green Deal.
Doping EU
Economies with Joint EU Bonds
This time
the idea seems to be to use joint EU bonds. Reuters writes: "The bigger amounts will have to come from some type of
centralized funding, because most budgets in Europe are relatively stretched,
particularly in Italy and France." As was stated in the infamous Draghi Report from Sept 2024: “the EU should move towards
regular issuance of common safe asset to enable joint investment project among
Member States and to help integrate capital markets”. Therefore,“common
issuance should over time produce a deeper and more liquid market in EU bonds”.
Joint EU
bonds are essentially bond issuances against the whole euro economy and would
thus entail a low risk and a lower interest rate than country level EU bonds.
This is perceived as necessary in order for the EU to hold its own in
competition with the USA and China that already have unified capital markets,
as a speech Draghi to the EU Commission last year made clear.
There are three main sources
of war financing: printing money, increasing taxes, and borrowing. Making
available “hundreds of billions” for the EU would likely be based on debt
issued from joint EU bonds. Bloomberg noted that if the spending were funded with tax increases, or cuts in other
areas, that could wipe out any positive impact—or worse. And any immediate
spending on the military would not help Europe because it would be mostly spent buying US weapons.
Therefore,
what the EU elite has in mind now is likely to put in place what F. Merz said;
a strategic independence from the US through a huge investment by joint EU
bonds, released and used over the long term in order to slowly build up
Europe’s industry, not only in the defense sector but also in other sectors.
The
EU Debt Plan is About Centralizing Financial Control
In a
sense, this would-be debt plan is just the European Union emulating the United
States playbook of using war for crony capitalist benefits, finally
“understanding” how to cynically exploit the Ukraine war, just as the US has
been doing since 2022 by feeding its Military Industrial Complex. But in order
for this to happen, the war must not end too soon for the European elite, which
is why efforts are made in order to – outrageously - spoil any US peace plans
and get the war to continue for now.
This plan
is the typical Keynesian militarist spending plan that European states were up
to already from WWI and onwards - and not only the fascists and the nazis, as John T. Flynn’s showed in his
essential book, As We Go Marching.
The
consequences over time of this public spending spree will be as disastrous for
Europe as they are obvious of course for students of the Austrian School of
Economics. It will, as always, lead to price inflation and devalue the Euro
currency, it will inflate bubbles, it will distort EU economies, it will lead
to malinvestments, and last but not least, it will leave small European
businesses, the backbone of Europe’s economies, hanging out to dry. It will
just kick the can down the road and allow EU government to postpone dealing
with their real structural problems, both economic and political. This is
particularly true for France.
But all
this is beside the point for the European elite, because from their point of
view this spending will artificially boost GDP in the many member states, it
will create qualified jobs with the defense and energy sectors all over Europe
and thus absorb some of the systemic unemployment which is a product of decades
of heavy state interventionism. It will allow further centralization and
harmonization of European economies to the benefit of power centralization in Bruxelles,
as it will instead drive for common defense platforms instead of the fragmented patchwork of defense suppliers that exist in Europe today. As
usual, the interests of the ruling minority diverge from the interest of the disorganized and
ruled majority.
Finally,
it will make current EU politicians more popular than now (which, admittedly,
isn’t hard), and it will benefit their careers and most likely their personal
wealth as well through all the kickbacks that they will get. The President of
the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen and many other EU bureaucratic parasites already know
this type of “business” well.
This, at
least, seems to be the plan. There should not be much political opposition to
it, since it would be political suicide to oppose a plan that “not only will
make Europe great again (MEGA), but also safer (from Russia)!”. The confirmed
victory of Merz’s CDU in Germany already made the potential political
opposition from the AfD lighter.
This is yet another case which shows that Western publics, not only in
Europe but also in the US, need to understand better that money creation whether
through debt or otherwise, and artificially pumping this money into the economy
will not be to their benefit. The negligeable benefits to the majority of such
policies can never justify their real objective of sustaining massive
bureaucratic states and increasing their control over society. It is therefore
as urgent as ever to continue to spread the knowledge and wisdom of Austrian
economics.
No comments:
Post a Comment